ATMs in New Carlisle, Indiana, the US. ATMs locations in New Carlisle, Indiana. Find the nearest atms locations, near you. All types of business services Accounting ATM Finance Insurance Lawyer Real estate School All atms in New Carlisle Access to Money ATM Finance 820 West Michigan Street, New Carlisle, Indiana 46552 Write a review Phone Website Directions ATM ATM Finance 820 West Michigan Street, New Carlisle, Indiana 46552 Write a review Phone Directions Wells Fargo ATM ATM Finance +1 800-869-3557 118 East Michigan Street, New Carlisle, Indiana 46552 Write a review Phone Website Directions